Navigation
Public engagement

Becoming a Scientist

Read online for free

Print your own copy

Virus Fighter

Build a virus or fight a pandemic!

Play online

Maya's Marvellous Medicine

Read online for free

Print your own copy

Battle Robots of the Blood

Read online for free

Print your own copy

Just for Kids! All about Coronavirus

Read online for free

Print your own copy

Archive
LabListon on Twitter
« Recreating the thymus | Main | The Placebo Effect »
Monday
Sep142009

Faith, post-modernism, science and the approximation of truth

Faith, post-modernism and science all have a different approach to truth.

With faith, the underlying premise (whether articulated or not) is that an Absolute Truth exists, and what is more that the believer has an insight into this Truth. Already knowing Truth, evidence contrary to this Truth must be false and can therefore be ignored. End of debate.

Post-modernism is either the opposite of faith, or just a subset of faith. Under post-modernist thought, there is no objective Truth or Reality, merely individual truths or realities that each person constructs for themselves. Every belief or truth then becomes equally valid, it is just as true to describe the sun as a galactic turnip as it is to talk about hydrogen fusion. Ironically enough, post-modernism does have unquestioning faith in one Truth, the Absolute Truth that there are no absolute truths. The irony is generally ignored.

Science has a third, and fundamentally different, way of conceptualising truth. Interestingly, science uses aspects of both the faith and post-modernistic concepts of truth. Science agrees with faith on the claim that there is an objective truth, or rather an objective reality, that exists independent of any observer. However science also agrees with post-modernism on the claim that an individual cannot grasp objective truth, only subjective truth. The unique contribution of science to the concept of truth is the approach of approximation.

Science does not claim to know Truth the way faith does, nor does it give up on the entire venture as a human abstraction the way post-modernism does. Instead science acknowledges that objective truth exists and attempts to reach the closest possible approximation of truth. Science starts with a model of reality. Scientists then attempt to disprove this model in every conceivable way. Inevitably, every model shows a flaw, an experiment which does not act in quite the predicted manner. The scientific model of objective truth / reality is then forced to change to explain the discordant data. Sometimes an entire model is discarded and a new model is picked up, but far more commonly the original model can continue to stand with a few modified improvements. Scientists then attack this modified model of the truth with renewed vigour. Cycle upon cycle, incremental improvements are made to the model, making it harder and harder to find flaws. Science will never be able to reach absolute truth, but it is extraordinary adept at producing an ever-increasingly accurate approximation of truth. The technology we take for granted today is just one display of how accurate scientific approximations of truth are – the scientific model of the atom does not claim perfection, but our daily use of electron flow (electricity) indicates that the scientific approximation is more functionally useful than any other statement of atomic Truth.

References (11)

References allow you to track sources for this article, as well as articles that were written in response to this article.
  • Response
    Jinzhou after the park opened, immediately triggered penang tourist boom
  • Response
    Response: aOtWXONJ
    Autoimmune Genetics - Immunology, genetics and the scientific method - Faith, post-modernism, science and the approximation of truth
  • Response
    Autoimmune Genetics - Immunology, genetics and the scientific method - Faith, post-modernism, science and the approximation of truth
  • Response
    Autoimmune Genetics - Immunology, genetics and the scientific method - Faith, post-modernism, science and the approximation of truth
  • Response
    Autoimmune Genetics - Immunology, genetics and the scientific method - Faith, post-modernism, science and the approximation of truth
  • Response
    Response: giubbotti moncler
    Autoimmune Genetics - Immunology, genetics and the scientific method - Faith, post-modernism, science and the approximation of truth
  • Response
    Autoimmune Genetics - Immunology, genetics and the scientific method - Faith, post-modernism, science and the approximation of truth
  • Response
    Autoimmune Genetics - Immunology, genetics and the scientific method - Faith, post-modernism, science and the approximation of truth
  • Response
    Response: UGG factory outlet
    Autoimmune Genetics - Immunology, genetics and the scientific method - Faith, post-modernism, science and the approximation of truth
  • Response
    Autoimmune Genetics - Immunology, genetics and the scientific method - Faith, post-modernism, science and the approximation of truth
  • Response
    Autoimmune Genetics - Immunology, genetics and the scientific method - Faith, post-modernism, science and the approximation of truth

Reader Comments (1)

nice good sharing post article information

April 15, 2014 | Unregistered Commenterobat lintah oil

PostPost a New Comment

Enter your information below to add a new comment.
Author Email (optional):
Author URL (optional):
Post:
 
Some HTML allowed: <a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <code> <em> <i> <strike> <strong>